• No results found

Parental involvement in education : a comparison between a privileged and underprivileged school.

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2023

Share "Parental involvement in education : a comparison between a privileged and underprivileged school."

Copied!
130
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

The objectives of the study were to identify the similarities and differences in parental involvement between advantaged and disadvantaged schools and why they exist. Parental involvement is influenced by many environmental factors that enable or limit parental involvement in schools.

INTRODUCTION

BACKGROUND TO THE STUDY

Furthermore, parents and educators have also realized that parental involvement in children's education is necessary. The lack of parental involvement in education is recognized by parents, teachers and learners (Naicker, 2013).

STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM

In my experience as a teacher in privileged and underprivileged schools, I find that there are different levels of parental involvement. None, to my knowledge, have focused solely on comparing parental involvement in privileged and underprivileged schools in South Africa, more specifically in Phoenix.

SIGNIFICANCE OF THE STUDY

5 third-party perspective, such as from teachers' (Bayat, Louw & Rena, 2014) and students' (Sedibe, 2012) views, thereby limiting parents' own voices. In practice, this study will contribute to schools regulating their activities to include parents, such as holding parent meetings at times convenient for parents.

FOCUS

Parents can also exchange ideas and practices with other parents and the same can happen with teachers and the schools.

OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY The objectives of this study are to

CRITICAL RESEARCH QUESTIONS

CLARIFICATION OF TERMINOLOGY

Furthermore, learners in disadvantaged schools are exempt from paying school fees and also have access to the National School Feeding Program (Education and Training Unit, 2014). In this study, a privileged school will be seen as those schools attended by middle-class children whose parents can pay school fees and run fundraising initiatives.

OVERVIEW OF THE RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY .1 Research Design

Sampling Procedure

In this study, the definition of an underprivileged school also includes a school where students are exempted from paying school fees because they cannot afford it, and they also participate in the national school feeding program. The data were generated using semi-structured interviews and open-ended questionnaires (McMillan & Schumacher, 2010).

Data Analysis

A semi-structured interview was used in this study because this allowed the researcher flexibility in questions during the interview (Miles & Gilbert, 2005). Johnson and Christensen (2013) stated that questionnaires that contain open-ended questions are called qualitative questionnaires, which the researcher can use to find out how the participants experience a phenomenon or why the participants believe that something is happening.

ETHICS

This allowed the researcher to further examine the participants' responses and cover aspects that may be important to the participant. Open-ended questions encourage participants to talk about their experiences and offer an understanding of how they see the world around them (Lankshear & Knobel, 2004).

ORGANISATION OF THE STUDY

Parental involvement in privileged and disadvantaged schools is examined from different contexts: an intercontinental, African and South African context. This theory offers six types of parental involvement that can be used to compare schools, and in this case, advantaged and disadvantaged schools.

CONCLUSION

The theoretical framework guiding this research is Epstein's Theory of Overlapping Spheres of Influence (Epstein, 1996). Chapter five outlines the summary of findings, recommendations for schools and recommendations for further research.

INTRODUCTION

UNDERSTANDING PARENTAL INVOLVEMENT

Thus, for the purpose of this study, parental involvement is defined as the participation of the parent, who can be defined as the biological parent or legal guardian, in the education of the child. Parental involvement is thus important for the learner, and its importance will be discussed in the next section.

RATIONALE FOR PARENTAL INVOLVEMENT

  • Learners’ Academic Achievement and Performance
  • Learners’ Aspiration
  • Self-esteem
  • Motivation
  • Self-Discipline and Behaviour
  • Benefit to Parents and Teachers

Parental involvement and expectations are also related because children tend to accept their parents' beliefs regarding achievement (Singh et al., 2004). 14 parental involvement increases learners' aspirations (Hill et al., 2004) and reduces the effects of poverty on education (Hango, 2007).

CONDITIONS CONSTRAINING PARENTS’ INVOLVEMENT IN SCHOOLS Teachers often think that parents are not interested in their children’s education (Hornby,

The privileged are more involved in their children's education, while the disadvantaged show very minimal participation. 22 British parents from both privileged and disadvantaged backgrounds are involved in their children's education.

PARENTAL INVOLVEMENT IN AFRICA

Single parents are less likely to be involved in their children's education than married parents (Chowa, Ansong & Osei-Akoto, 2012b). Sottie (2011) found that single parents in Ghana are not involved in their children's education because of their economic status.

PARENTAL INVOLVEMENT IN SOUTH AFRICA

Bhengu (2003) found that parents in poor schools do not attend parent meetings about their children. Parents do not even attend parent meetings or come to collect their children's report cards (Mbokodi, 2008; Mbokodi & Singh, 2011).

THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK

Recognition of the shared responsibilities between educators and parents pushes the spheres of family and school influence together and increases interaction between the school and parent (Epstein, 1996). The parents recruit and organize help and support for the school and student activities (Epstein & Sheldon, 2005).

Figure  2.1  The  overlapping  spheres  of  influence  related  to  parental  involvement  (Adapted from Epstein, 1997, p.72)
Figure 2.1 The overlapping spheres of influence related to parental involvement (Adapted from Epstein, 1997, p.72)

CONCLUSION

INTRODUCTION

RESEARCH APPROACH

The researcher is generally an observer in the environment under investigation, as an interviewer, observer or document and artefact collector and obtains data directly from the source. The focus is on participants' perspectives on the meaning of events and actions and "involves multiple realities as different people construct meaning from the same event" (p. 321). There was no control, manipulation and externally imposed restrictions on the participants; the researcher observed the setting as an interviewer and the study focused on the participant's perspectives on parental involvement in both the privileged and underprivileged school, involving the multiple realities constructed by participants from the same event.

RESEARCH PARADIGM

Furthermore, the researcher would be the instrument for generating data (Johnson & Christensen, 2010). Because people are different, they view the world in different ways, so the interpretivist focuses on the perspectives of individuals and groups of individuals (O'Hara et al., 2011). Interpretivism attempts to represent how participants make choices in social situations (Burton & Bartlett, 2005) by interpreting and responding to events (Bartlett & Burton, 2012).

RESEARCH DESIGN

39 Within a case study, the researcher can do a single case study, a multiple case study, or a collective case study (Gay et al., 2009). This study used a multiple case study, which includes more than one case study that is related in some way (Day Ashley, 2012). The two cases in this study were schools that are related in terms of parental involvement.

SAMPLING

The Study Site

  • Brief Description of the Sampled Schools

This can be seen in the suburbs in which students live, their clothing, their homes and their ability to pay school fees. The majority of students come from poor backgrounds as most parents are unemployed or do not have permanent jobs. Their poverty is also evident from the clothing and homes of the students the researcher has seen.

The Participants

  • Brief Description of Silver Oak Primary School Participants
  • Brief Description of Riverside Primary School Participants

In addition, students at this school rely on the National School Food Program for their daily lunch. 41 Parents were part of the sample because the study focused on their involvement and thus they provided relevant information that was needed. Interviewee Gender Age Highest qualification Nature of work Parent 1 F 33 Exemption from Matric Employed in a call center.

Figure 3.1 Profile of Interviewees (Silver Oak teachers)
Figure 3.1 Profile of Interviewees (Silver Oak teachers)

DATA GENERATION PROCESS

Interview: Semi-structured Interview

A semi-structured interview was used in this study because it gives the researcher flexibility in asking questions during the interview (Miles & Gilbert, 2005). This allowed the researcher to further explore participant responses and capture aspects that may be relevant to the participant. Participants may also mention an aspect of the study that the researcher may not have previously considered (Naicker, 2013).

DATA ANALYSIS

The researcher became familiar with the data by transcription, followed by a careful reading and re-reading of the data and noted ideas, as suggested by (Braun & Clarke, 2006). Reliability refers to the research being trusted over time and requires the researcher to thoroughly document the context in which the research was conducted (Major & Savin-Baden, 2010). Confirmability refers to the researcher being neutral in data analysis and interpretation (Major & Savin-Baden, 2010).

ETHICS

Permission to collect data was also sorted from the schools involved and the DBE before the study was conducted. They were made aware of the purpose of the study and of their right to withdraw at any time. According to Nojaja (2009), research participants should have the opportunity to participate and be made aware of the nature of the study; and have the right to withdraw from the study.

LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY

The real names of the schools and participants involved will not be disclosed, pseudonyms will be used. No participants were harmed in this study and no identifying information about each participant was revealed.

CONCLUSION

INTRODUCTION

DATA ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION

Care and Support of Children by Parents

Data shows that generally, parents from both privileged and disadvantaged communities are involved in their children's education. Thus, the above responses indicate that participants from both the privileged and disadvantaged communities are involved in their children's school work. This implies that parents know that they should be involved in school affairs and in their children's education, as stated in SASA (RSA, 1996b).

Ecological Factors that Enable Parental Involvement in School

Parents at Riverside Primary feel they are not adequately involved in their children's education because of time. 78 are involved and encouraged to be part of their children's education." (Parent 3, Silver Oak School). School leadership and support also strategize on ways to involve parents in their children's education.

CONCLUSION

INTRODUCTION

SUMMARY OF FINDINGS

Experiences of Parental Involvement within Privileged and Underprivileged Schools

At the disadvantaged school, although some parents may be able to participate in school activities such as deb's prom and sports, not all parents can participate or help with activities. The teachers and parents agree that parental involvement in the school is essential for children's academic and holistic development. In the privileged school, parental involvement is active and high, while it is minimal in the disadvantaged school.

Ecological Factors that Enable and Constrain Parental Involvement within the Schools

Thus, the attendance rate of parents at meetings is lower in the disadvantaged school than in the privileged school. More parents are suggested to be involved in the privileged school than in the less privileged school. The privileged school also has a higher attendance rate at parent meetings than the less privileged school.

RECOMMENDATIONS

The School Leadership

The Action Team can consist of three teachers, three parents and a social worker, or a community member willing to serve on the team (van Wyk & Lemmer, 2009). Resources can be provided to parents, such as information books, audio tapes, parenting guides and a school activities chart that parents can get involved with. The newsletters can be done in either English or isiZulu, or in the appropriate home language of the school. .

Tertiary Institutions and the Government

The school can also offer lessons to parents and encourage them to pass the matriculation exam or other education for parents who have not finished school. The government can also play a role by providing parents with a scholarship to continue their studies.

RECOMMENDATIONS FOR FURTHER RESEARCH

Effects of parental involvement in education: a case study in Namibia (Unpublished Master of Education Thesis). The research topic is PARENT INVOLVEMENT IN EDUCATION: COMPARISON BETWEEN A PRIVILEGE AND AN UNPRIVILEGED SCHOOL. The title of my research is, Parental involvement in education: a comparison between a privileged and underprivileged school.

Nature of the research project

What is required of participants I understand that

Did the school allow parents to be part of the decision-making process? If so, talk about it. Do you know when your child is writing tests and exams or has a project. Do you take your child on visits to places that would be educationally interesting?

Figure

Figure  2.1  The  overlapping  spheres  of  influence  related  to  parental  involvement  (Adapted from Epstein, 1997, p.72)
Figure 3.1 Profile of Interviewees (Silver Oak teachers)
Figure 3.4 Profile of Interviewees (Riverside parents)
Figure 4.1 Themes in relation to parental involvement in schools in Phoenix

References

Related documents

Alternative methods, such as telephonic interviews (24) and home visits (30) were used to obtain information from subjects who d id n o t attend the postnatal clinic. Comparisons

This understanding of early school leaving led to an exploration of literature to learn about the causes of school dropout from the perspectives of social work, psychology,

This community in which the school is based is well-known for high crime levels, huge school (primary and high) drop-out rates, teenage pregnancy, single parent homes and large

The definition of parental involvement according to the Department of Education in the United States 2004, is the participation of parents in regular, two-way and meaningful

Research suggests that there is a significant relationship between the levels of parental/caregiver monitoring and adolescent involvement in risk-taking behaviour, especially pertaining

This study aims to explore how Grade ten and eleven learners, parents and Life Orientation educators experiences of the role of parental involvement in the psychosocial development of

t ABSTRACT This research project attempted to investigate the Management of the School-Parent Relationships in a Primary School .The aims of this study were to determine to what

Red Star Secondary School teacher 2 Excell Secondary School parent 2 aptly stated, “democratic schools will see to it that individuals representing the various groups like the