This research project aimed to investigate the effects of particle size distribution (PSD) on the shrink-core model (SKM) for determining the control regime of the ammonium thiosulphate leaching of gold from waste mobile phone PCBs. These PSD models were used to estimate the central values (median and mean magnitudes) and covariances of the PSDs.
Background to Research Problem
Over the years, hydrometallurgical treatment of electronic waste has replaced pyrometallurgical methods due to its lower environmental footprint, ease of operation and relatively higher metal extraction efficiency (Cui & Anderson, 2016; Hanafi et al., 2012; Grosse et al. , 2003). Thiosulfate has been praised for its higher selectivity, lower toxicity and corrosiveness (Hanafi et al., 2012; Grosse et al., 2003).
Statement of Research Problem
The leaching process is a series of diffusion stages between the liquid and solid phase as well as kinetic stages. Previous research has established that neglecting the PSD can lead to erroneous conclusions regarding the control regime of the leaching process when modeling with the SCM is performed (Prosser, 1996; Gbor & Jia, 2004).
Research Questions
However, there is still a gap in the body of knowledge regarding the impact of incorporating the PSD and PD into the shrinking core model (SCM) to describe the thiosulfate leaching of gold from waste mobile phone printed circuit boards.
Research Aim and Objectives
Research Hypothesis
Scope of this Study
Thesis Outline
Electronic Waste
Mobile Phone Printed Circuit Boards (PCBs)
2006) state that mobile phone and computer printed circuit boards differ in that computer PCBs are not multiplayer. A mobile phone consists of a polymer fraction, a printed circuit board (PCB), crystal liquid display (LCD), battery, keypad and an antenna (Kasper et al., 2011).
Characterisation of Mobile Phone PCBs
General E-Waste Processing Scheme
The pre-treatment or refining phase is of crucial importance because it frees the PCB particles from the unwanted non-metallic fraction. It is performed by mechanical-physical separation phases based on physical, magnetic and electrical properties of the PCB constituents (J. Guo et al., 2015; X. Guo et al., 2015).
Metal Extraction by Pyrometallurgy
Copper smelter feed includes domestic concentrates, imported concentrates and spent secondary waste. Potential loss of precious and base metals from slag caused by the presence of ceramic components in e-waste. iv) Incomplete separation of metals is currently achievable, which makes the pyrometallurgical technique more suitable as a pre-treatment operation.
Metal Extraction by Hydrometallurgy
- Aqua Regia
- Cyanide Leaching
- Halide Leaching
- Thiourea Leaching
- Thiosulphate Leaching
- Metal Extraction by Biohydrometallurgy
- Comparison of Current Leaching Technologies
However, several studies have reported adverse environmental effects due to the significant amount of cyanide-containing wastewater produced (Zhang et al., 2012). According to La Brooy et al. 1994), the use of halide systems for dissolving gold predates cyanidation. The use of thiourea ((𝑁𝐻2)2𝐶𝑆) as a gold leaching agent has shown promise to extract gold from ores (Veglio et al., 2003).
It is also used in the extraction of other base metals such as nickel and zinc (Rohwerder et al., 2003). However, many of the investigations in this field have focused on copper and gold as metals of interest (Baniasadi et al., 2019).
Ammonium Thiosulphate Leaching of Gold from E-waste
Leaching Mechanism
According to Isildar et al., (2017), the presence of ammonium ions and cupric ions in the leach system promotes the complex formation of precious metals such as gold and silver. Cupric ion acts as a catalyst in the dissolution reaction and NH4+ as a stabilizer of the system, thereby accelerating the anodic dissolution. According to Molleman & Dreisinger (2002), the chemistry of the ammoniacal thiosulfate system for gold mining involves many interrelated chemical equilibria that are not yet fully understood.
This complexity can be attributed to the presence of the three essential components involved in the leaching system, namely ammonia, thiosulphate and copper (Aylmore, 2016). Previous studies have reported that this leaching process is strictly dependent on pH in the range of 9-10, and operates at ambient temperature to further enhance the thermodynamic stability of the Cu(II)-ammonia-thiosulfate system (Perez & Galaviz, 1987 Zipperian et al. al., 1988; Molleman & Dreisinger, 2002).
Factors Influencing the Ammonium Thiosulphate Leaching of Gold
- Thermodynamics
- Temperature
- Thiosulphate Concentration
- Ammonia Concentration
- Cupric Ion Concentration
- Particle Size
Higher pH conditions can cause sulfide formation, which, in turn, reduces gold extraction efficiency (Zipperian et al., 1988). According to Hung et al. 2011), due to the activation energy exceeding 25 kJ.mol-1, the reaction is chemically controlled. At higher pH values>9, however, gold dissolution becomes independent of ammonia concentration and dependent on thiosulfate concentration, suggesting that the complex 𝐴𝑢(𝑆2𝑂3)23− is more dominant than 𝐴𝑢(𝑁𝝐3)2+ ., 2010).
According to Bell et al. 1995), the most important thiosulphate leaching parameters include temperature, oxygen partial pressure and ammonia concentration. According to Tripathi et al. 2012), the presence of copper ions promotes the dissolution of gold in the thiosulphate solution.
Previous Studies on the Thiosulphate Leaching of Gold from E-waste
Thus it can be argued that a significant increase in gold dissolution can be achieved by reducing the PCB particle size. Furthermore, Cu layers cover most of the surface of a typical PCB, which means that Au will leach out with more strain from full-size PCBs (Li & Miller, 2007; Wei et al investigated the effect of particle size on acid thioureamination of gold from milled central processing units (CPUs) with particle sizes smaller than 3 and 0.1 mm The gold extracts obtained were 18.2 and 82%, respectively, showing improvement significantly with smaller particle sizes as a result of improved contact area between the particles and the solution.
Shrinking-Core Model for the Predictive Analysis of Thiosulphate Leaching
The shrinking core model outlined in this section applies only to particles of constant size. The SCM conversion time expressions for non-shrinking particles are given in Table 2-5 and graphically in Figure 2-16. The variable (1 – X) describes the shrinkage of the unconverted core and is directly linked to the conversion.
As the reaction progresses, a gradual increase in conversion is accompanied by a decrease in the unreacted core until all the solid reactant is converted and the remaining particles are converted to ash. The SCM is expressed in terms of unreacted core shrinkage and fractional time for complete conversion, which helps determine the rate-limiting rate of the reactive system (Levenspiel, 1999; Othusitse & Muzenda, 2015).
Previous Work on the Shrinking-Core Model in Hydrometallurgy
Particle Size Distribution and Shrinking-Core Model
Equation (25) can be used for chemical reaction control and liquid film diffusion control since 𝑓(𝐷, 𝑡) can be expressed algebraically for these mechanisms. Equation (25) can be solved numerically using available third-party software packages and libraries. Gbor & Jia (2004) showed that when the covariance or CV coefficient of variation of the particle size distribution can be used to assess whether PSD can be included and excluded from the shrinkage kernel model when determining the limiting rate step or control regime of a drainage process.
The authors indicated that for CV values less than 0.3, the linear relationship between 1 − (1 − 𝑋)1 3⁄ and 𝑡 is maintained for chemical reaction control and PSD can be excluded from SCM. For systems with higher CV values (>0.7), ignoring the PSD will erroneously switch the leaching mechanism from liquid film diffusion to ash diffusion.
Research Design
PCB Size Reduction
Unused mobile phones of various makes and models were collected from various local mobile phone outlets.
Aqua Regia Leaching
Ammonium Thiosulphate Leaching
PCBs were added and the reaction mixture was adjusted to 500 mL with deionized water. The temperature of the mixture was adjusted to 30°C and the pH of the solution was adjusted and maintained at 9.5 with the aid of ammonia solution. The leaching process was allowed to proceed for 3 h, and leachate samples were collected every 30 min for metal analysis by AAS.
Description of Experimental Apparatus
Description of Materials
- Ammonium Thiosulphate
- Copper Sulphate
- Ammonia Solution
- Nitric Acid
- Hydrochloric Acid
It is a blue crystalline salt and regulates the redox potential of the thiosulphate leaching system. It was therefore used in a fume hood with the appropriate protective equipment (respiratory mask, laboratory gloves, safety glasses and shoes). Nitric acid is a strong acid that was used in combination with hydrochloric acid to form aqua regia.
Personal Protection Equipment
Particle Size Distributions
Not only were the GGS and RR models used to estimate the mean magnitude of the PSDs, but they were also used to determine covariances based on the best model fit to the data. It is worth noting that the covariance was used to assess the requirement to incorporate the PSD in the SCM characterization of the leaching process which is further discussed in section 4.4. However, an examination of Figure 4-3 indicates that RR model better fits PSD 2 to 4 due to the closeness of predicted and actual median (D50) magnitudes compared to the GGS model.
These results are in agreement with the literature as the GGS and RR models have been reported to characterize the size distribution of large and small particles, respectively (Gbor & Jia, 2004; Ahmed & Ahmed, 2008). These results are discussed in connection with gold mining and the shrinking core model in the rest of the chapter.
Gold Extraction
Reducing pulp density from 120 to 40 g/L improved gold dissolution from average values of 35 to 80. Increasing pulp density resulted in excess PCB solids, making thiosulfate the limiting reagent. Particle size distribution had a significant effect on gold extraction at the lowest pulp density of 40 g/L.
The gold extraction was found to fluctuate between 40 and 50% at 80 g/l pulp density and between 35 and 40% at 120 g/l pulp density, with no clear behavioral pattern of gold extraction with PSD variation. Therefore, based on the experimental results presented in Figure 4-4, it can be concluded that the effect of the pulp density variation was more pronounced than the particle size distribution variation in terms of gold extraction.
Statistical Analysis of Leaching Results
Overall, the estimated marginal means of gold extraction (Figure 4-5) also support the higher significance of the pulp density variation compared to PSD due to the higher variation in gold extraction obtained at different pulp densities compared to different PSDs.
Particle Size Distribution, Shrinking-Core Model and Rate-limiting Mechanism . 56
Particle Size Distribution in SCM Characterisation
SCM fitting to Thiosulphate Leaching Data
At higher pulp densities (80 and 120 g/L), the unreacted core size reductions did not reach satisfactory levels, regardless of the PSD level. None of the predictive mechanisms of the SCM fit the kinetic data (see the model fitting plots in Figure C-1 and Figure C-2 of Appendix C). In addition, they hampered the application of the shrink core model to describe, predict and provide insight into the rate-limiting mechanism of the leaching process.
The possible explanation for the SCM not fitting the leaching data, for larger particles with low pulp density and all particle sizes with higher pulp density, is that the leaching kinetics under these conditions may be influenced by any of the following factors (which were not considered in this research): (i) SCM assumes that a single general parameter, the effective diffusivity (including all mechanical resistances to leaching) can adequately describe the transfer of mass within a reacting solid particle, which can lead to difficulties in implementing SCM for data mining (Liddell, 2005); (ii) the pseudo-steady state assumption (PSSA) of SCM as presented by Levenspiel (1999) suggests that there is a discrete interface between the reacted and unreacted solids sections, but this assumption does not apply to all drainage systems (Liddell, 2005); iii) the effects of mechanical agitation-induced particle disruption and segregation on leaching kinetics (Velardo et al., 2002). The control regime can be further isolated by determining the activation energy of the flushing process (Gbor & Jia, 2004; Crundwell et al., 2013; Khezri et al., 2020).
Conclusion
Recommendation for Future Research
Precious metal recovery from waste printed circuit boards using cyanide and non-cyanide lixiviants - a review. Recovery of precious metals from waste printed circuit boards using thiosulphate leaching and ion exchange resin. Recovery of metallic values from waste printed circuit boards using an alkali fusion-leaching-separation process.
Extraction of gold, silver, copper and niobium from printed circuits using the leaching column technique. A new process for extracting precious metals from scrap printed circuit boards: using gold concentrate as a fluxing material. Leaching of gold from waste mobile phone printed circuit boards (PCBs) with ammonium thiosulphate.
Bioleaching of copper from waste printed circuit boards by a bacterial consortium enriched with acid mine drainage.